caddy-frontend: Improve validation with decoupled configuration state calculation

Validation happens on each configuration change, but for sure it is checked
each 2 hours.

State of configuration is calculated in separate script.

software/caddy-frontend/buildout.hash.cfg

@@ -22,7 +22,7 @@ md5sum = c801b7f9f11f0965677c22e6bbe9281b
 
 [template-apache-frontend]
 filename = instance-apache-frontend.cfg.in
-md5sum = 77b06f3a7bf67c990a363f8d5155596c
+md5sum = ade2eb66b2123d7f8ff5df5a37720dbe
 
 [template-apache-replicate]
 filename = instance-apache-replicate.cfg.in
@@ -94,11 +94,15 @@ md5sum = b9f73f6323f9fceea054c46c854d2862
 
 [template-graceful-script]
 filename = templates/graceful-script.sh.in
-md5sum = 959f49437cffb096368f0b6434f06d3d
+md5sum = 061cc244558fd3af2b6bacf17cae5555
 
 [template-validate-script]
 filename = templates/validate-script.sh.in
-md5sum = 3174bf29f439d14e292f8719bba19a7a
+md5sum = 89839a3f4ab71cab459afd1c27d00326
+
+[template-configuration-state-script]
+filename = templates/configuration-state-script.sh.in
+md5sum = 00dfdc488548d1b14e89ba5f2f08fcb8
 
 [template-rotate-script]
 filename = templates/rotate-script.sh.in

software/caddy-frontend/common.cfg

@@ -122,6 +122,7 @@ template_caddy_frontend_configuration = ${template-caddy-frontend-configuration:
 template_graceful_script = ${template-graceful-script:target}
 template_validate_script = ${template-validate-script:target}
 template_rotate_script = ${template-rotate-script:target}
+template_configuration_state_script = ${template-configuration-state-script:target}
 template_caddy_lazy_script_call = ${template-caddy-lazy-script-call:target}
 template_default_slave_virtualhost = ${template-default-slave-virtualhost:target}
 template_empty = ${template-empty:target}
@@ -256,6 +257,10 @@ filename = graceful-script.sh.in
 <=download-template
 filename = validate-script.sh.in
 
+[template-configuration-state-script]
+<=download-template
+filename = configuration-state-script.sh.in
+
 # Migrated from KVM recipe
 [http-proxy]
 # https://github.com/nodejitsu/node-http-proxy

software/caddy-frontend/instance-apache-frontend.cfg.in

@@ -9,7 +9,6 @@ extends =
 
 parts =
   directory
-  configtest
   logrotate-entry-caddy
   caddy-frontend
   switch-caddy-softwaretype
@@ -371,8 +370,7 @@ frontend-configuration = ${directory:etc}/Caddyfile
 access-log = ${directory:log}/frontend-access.log
 error-log = ${directory:log}/frontend-error.log
 pid-file = ${directory:run}/httpd.pid
-frontend-configuration-verification = ${frontend-caddy-validate:rendered}
-frontend-graceful-command = ${:frontend-configuration-verification} && kill -USR1 $(cat ${:pid-file})
+frontend-graceful-command = ${frontend-caddy-validate:rendered} && kill -USR1 $(cat ${:pid-file})
 not-found-file = ${caddy-directory:document-root}/notfound.html
 master-certificate = ${caddy-directory:master-autocert-dir}/master.pem
 # Communication with ATS
@@ -380,11 +378,6 @@ cache-port = ${trafficserver-variable:input-port}
 cache-through-port = 26011
 ssl-cache-through-port = 26012
 
-[configtest]
-recipe = slapos.cookbook:wrapper
-command-line = ${frontend-caddy-validate:rendered}
-wrapper-path = ${directory:bin}/caddy-configtest
-
 # BBB: SlapOS Master non-zero knowledge BEGIN
 [get-self-signed-fallback-access]
 recipe = collective.recipe.shelloutput
@@ -569,33 +562,48 @@ command = ${trafficserver-rotate-script:rendered}
 ### End of ATS sections
 
 ### Caddy Graceful and promises
-[frontend-caddy-graceful]
+[frontend-caddy-configuration-state]
 < = jinja2-template-base
-template = {{ parameter_dict['template_graceful_script'] }}
-rendered = ${directory:etc-run}/frontend-caddy-safe-graceful
+template = {{ parameter_dict['template_configuration_state_script'] }}
+rendered = ${directory:bin}/${:_buildout_section_name_}
 mode = 0700
 
 path_list = ${caddy-configuration:frontend-configuration} ${frontend-configuration:log-access-configuration} ${caddy-directory:slave-configuration}/*.conf ${caddy-directory:slave-with-cache-configuration}/*.conf ${caddy-directory:master-autocert-dir}/*.key ${caddy-directory:master-autocert-dir}/*.crt ${caddy-directory:master-autocert-dir}/*.pem ${caddy-directory:autocert}/*.pem ${caddy-directory:custom-ssl-directory}/*.proxy_ca_crt ${directory:bbb-ssl-dir}/*.crt
 sha256sum = {{ parameter_dict['sha256sum'] }}
-signature_file = ${directory:run}/caddy_graceful_signature
+
 extra-context =
-    key graceful_reload_command caddy-configuration:frontend-graceful-command
     key path_list :path_list
     key sha256sum :sha256sum
     key signature_file :signature_file
 
+[frontend-caddy-configuration-state-graceful]
+< = frontend-caddy-configuration-state
+signature_file = ${directory:run}/graceful_configuration_state_signature
+
+[frontend-caddy-configuration-state-validate]
+< = frontend-caddy-configuration-state
+signature_file = ${directory:run}/validate_configuration_state_signature
+
+[frontend-caddy-graceful]
+< = jinja2-template-base
+template = {{ parameter_dict['template_graceful_script'] }}
+rendered = ${directory:etc-run}/frontend-caddy-safe-graceful
+mode = 0700
+
+extra-context =
+    key graceful_reload_command caddy-configuration:frontend-graceful-command
+    key caddy_configuration_state frontend-caddy-configuration-state-graceful:rendered
+
 [frontend-caddy-validate]
 < = jinja2-template-base
 template = {{ parameter_dict['template_validate_script'] }}
 rendered = ${directory:bin}/frontend-caddy-validate
 mode = 0700
-sha256sum = {{ parameter_dict['sha256sum'] }}
-signature_file = ${directory:run}/caddy_validate_signature
+last_state_file = ${directory:run}/caddy_configuration_last_state
 extra-context =
     key wrapper caddy-wrapper:wrapper-path
-    key path_list frontend-caddy-graceful:path_list
-    key sha256sum :sha256sum
-    key signature_file :signature_file
+    key caddy_configuration_state frontend-caddy-configuration-state-validate:rendered
+    key last_state_file :last_state_file
 
 [frontend-caddy-lazy-graceful]
 < = jinja2-template-base

software/caddy-frontend/templates/configuration-state-script.sh.in

+#!/bin/sh
+
+set -e
+SIGNATURE_FILE={{ signature_file }}
+NSIGNATURE_FILE={{ signature_file }}.tmp
+
+touch $SIGNATURE_FILE
+{{ sha256sum }} {{ path_list }} 2> /dev/null | sort -k 66 > $NSIGNATURE_FILE
+
+if diff "$SIGNATURE_FILE" "$NSIGNATURE_FILE" > /dev/null ; then
+  rm -f ${NSIGNATURE_FILE}
+  exit 1
+else
+  mv "$NSIGNATURE_FILE" "$SIGNATURE_FILE"
+  exit 0
+fi

software/caddy-frontend/templates/graceful-script.sh.in

 #!/bin/sh
 
-SIGNATURE_FILE={{ signature_file }}
-NSIGNATURE_FILE={{ signature_file }}.tmp
+set -e
 
-touch $SIGNATURE_FILE
-{{ sha256sum }} {{ path_list }} 2> /dev/null | sort -k 66 > $NSIGNATURE_FILE
-
-# If no diff, no restart for now
-if diff "$SIGNATURE_FILE" "$NSIGNATURE_FILE" > /dev/null ; then
+if {{ caddy_configuration_state }} ; then
+  echo "Reloading.."
+  {{ graceful_reload_command }}
+else
   echo "Nothing changed, so nothing to reload"
   exit 0
 fi
-echo "Reloading.."
-
-{{ graceful_reload_command }}
-
-mv "$NSIGNATURE_FILE" "$SIGNATURE_FILE"

software/caddy-frontend/templates/validate-script.sh.in

@@ -2,21 +2,16 @@
 
 set -e
 
-SIGNATURE_FILE={{ signature_file }}
-NSIGNATURE_FILE={{ signature_file }}.tmp
-SIGNATURE_STATUS={{ signature_file }}.status
+LAST_STATE_FILE={{ last_state_file }}
 
-touch $SIGNATURE_FILE
-{{ sha256sum }} {{ path_list }} 2> /dev/null | sort -k 66 > $NSIGNATURE_FILE
-
-if diff "$SIGNATURE_FILE" "$NSIGNATURE_FILE" > /dev/null; then
-  rm -f "$NSIGNATURE_FILE"
-else
-  mv "$NSIGNATURE_FILE" "$SIGNATURE_FILE"
+# force validation each 2 hours
+[ -f $LAST_STATE_FILE ] && find $LAST_STATE_FILE -mmin +120 -delete
+configuration_state=$({{ caddy_configuration_state }})
+if [ ! -f $LAST_STATE_FILE ] || $configuration_state ; then
   # do not catch errors during validation
   set +e
   {{ wrapper }} -validate
-  echo $? > $SIGNATURE_STATUS
+  echo $? > $LAST_STATE_FILE
   set -e
 fi
-exit `cat $SIGNATURE_STATUS`
+exit `cat $LAST_STATE_FILE`

software/caddy-frontend/test/test.py

@@ -343,8 +343,6 @@ class TestDataMixin(object):
     self._test_file_list(['var', 'run'], [
       # run by cron from time to time
       'monitor/monitor-collect.pid',
-      # may appear or not
-      'caddy_graceful_signature.tmp',
     ])
 
   def test_file_list_etc_cron_d(self):
@@ -392,6 +390,12 @@ class TestDataMixin(object):
         plugin = plugin_path[strip:]
         if plugin in ignored_plugin_list:
           continue
+        # reset frontend-caddy-configuration-promise.py state
+        if plugin == 'frontend-caddy-configuration-promise.py':
+          validate_path = os.path.join(
+            partition_path, 'bin', 'frontend-caddy-validate')
+          if os.path.exists(validate_path):
+            subprocess_status_output(validate_path)
         plugin_status, plugin_result = subprocess_status_output([
           runpromise_bin,
           '-c', monitor_conf,

software/caddy-frontend/test/test_data/test.TestDuplicateSiteKeyProtection.test_file_list_run-CADDY.txt

@@ -2,9 +2,9 @@ T-0/var/run/monitor-httpd.pid
 T-0/var/run/monitor/monitor-bootstrap.pid
 T-1/var/run/kedifa.pid
 T-1/var/run/monitor/monitor-bootstrap.pid
-T-2/var/run/caddy_graceful_signature
-T-2/var/run/caddy_validate_signature
-T-2/var/run/caddy_validate_signature.status
+T-2/var/run/caddy_configuration_last_state
+T-2/var/run/graceful_configuration_state_signature
 T-2/var/run/httpd.pid
 T-2/var/run/monitor-httpd.pid
 T-2/var/run/monitor/monitor-bootstrap.pid
+T-2/var/run/validate_configuration_state_signature
\ No newline at end of file

software/caddy-frontend/test/test_data/test.TestEnableHttp2ByDefaultDefaultSlave.test_file_list_run-CADDY.txt

@@ -2,9 +2,9 @@ T-0/var/run/monitor-httpd.pid
 T-0/var/run/monitor/monitor-bootstrap.pid
 T-1/var/run/kedifa.pid
 T-1/var/run/monitor/monitor-bootstrap.pid
-T-2/var/run/caddy_graceful_signature
-T-2/var/run/caddy_validate_signature
-T-2/var/run/caddy_validate_signature.status
+T-2/var/run/caddy_configuration_last_state
+T-2/var/run/graceful_configuration_state_signature
 T-2/var/run/httpd.pid
 T-2/var/run/monitor-httpd.pid
 T-2/var/run/monitor/monitor-bootstrap.pid
+T-2/var/run/validate_configuration_state_signature
\ No newline at end of file

software/caddy-frontend/test/test_data/test.TestEnableHttp2ByDefaultDefaultSlaveGlobalDisableHttp2.test_file_list_run-CADDY.txt

@@ -2,9 +2,9 @@ T-0/var/run/monitor-httpd.pid
 T-0/var/run/monitor/monitor-bootstrap.pid
 T-1/var/run/kedifa.pid
 T-1/var/run/monitor/monitor-bootstrap.pid
-T-2/var/run/caddy_graceful_signature
-T-2/var/run/caddy_validate_signature
-T-2/var/run/caddy_validate_signature.status
+T-2/var/run/caddy_configuration_last_state
+T-2/var/run/graceful_configuration_state_signature
 T-2/var/run/httpd.pid
 T-2/var/run/monitor-httpd.pid
 T-2/var/run/monitor/monitor-bootstrap.pid
+T-2/var/run/validate_configuration_state_signature
\ No newline at end of file

software/caddy-frontend/test/test_data/test.TestEnableHttp2ByDefaultFalseSlave.test_file_list_run-CADDY.txt

@@ -2,9 +2,9 @@ T-0/var/run/monitor-httpd.pid
 T-0/var/run/monitor/monitor-bootstrap.pid
 T-1/var/run/kedifa.pid
 T-1/var/run/monitor/monitor-bootstrap.pid
-T-2/var/run/caddy_graceful_signature
-T-2/var/run/caddy_validate_signature
-T-2/var/run/caddy_validate_signature.status
+T-2/var/run/caddy_configuration_last_state
+T-2/var/run/graceful_configuration_state_signature
 T-2/var/run/httpd.pid
 T-2/var/run/monitor-httpd.pid
 T-2/var/run/monitor/monitor-bootstrap.pid
+T-2/var/run/validate_configuration_state_signature
\ No newline at end of file

software/caddy-frontend/test/test_data/test.TestEnableHttp2ByDefaultFalseSlaveGlobalDisableHttp2.test_file_list_run-CADDY.txt

@@ -2,9 +2,9 @@ T-0/var/run/monitor-httpd.pid
 T-0/var/run/monitor/monitor-bootstrap.pid
 T-1/var/run/kedifa.pid
 T-1/var/run/monitor/monitor-bootstrap.pid
-T-2/var/run/caddy_graceful_signature
-T-2/var/run/caddy_validate_signature
-T-2/var/run/caddy_validate_signature.status
+T-2/var/run/caddy_configuration_last_state
+T-2/var/run/graceful_configuration_state_signature
 T-2/var/run/httpd.pid
 T-2/var/run/monitor-httpd.pid
 T-2/var/run/monitor/monitor-bootstrap.pid
+T-2/var/run/validate_configuration_state_signature
\ No newline at end of file

software/caddy-frontend/test/test_data/test.TestMalformedBackenUrlSlave.test_file_list_run-CADDY.txt

@@ -2,9 +2,9 @@ T-0/var/run/monitor-httpd.pid
 T-0/var/run/monitor/monitor-bootstrap.pid
 T-1/var/run/kedifa.pid
 T-1/var/run/monitor/monitor-bootstrap.pid
-T-2/var/run/caddy_graceful_signature
-T-2/var/run/caddy_validate_signature
-T-2/var/run/caddy_validate_signature.status
+T-2/var/run/caddy_configuration_last_state
+T-2/var/run/graceful_configuration_state_signature
 T-2/var/run/httpd.pid
 T-2/var/run/monitor-httpd.pid
 T-2/var/run/monitor/monitor-bootstrap.pid
+T-2/var/run/validate_configuration_state_signature
\ No newline at end of file

software/caddy-frontend/test/test_data/test.TestMasterRequest.test_file_list_run-CADDY.txt

@@ -2,8 +2,8 @@ T-0/var/run/monitor-httpd.pid
 T-0/var/run/monitor/monitor-bootstrap.pid
 T-1/var/run/kedifa.pid
 T-1/var/run/monitor/monitor-bootstrap.pid
-T-2/var/run/caddy_graceful_signature
-T-2/var/run/caddy_validate_signature
-T-2/var/run/caddy_validate_signature.status
+T-2/var/run/caddy_configuration_last_state
+T-2/var/run/graceful_configuration_state_signature
 T-2/var/run/httpd.pid
 T-2/var/run/monitor/monitor-bootstrap.pid
+T-2/var/run/validate_configuration_state_signature
\ No newline at end of file

software/caddy-frontend/test/test_data/test.TestMasterRequestDomain.test_file_list_run-CADDY.txt

@@ -2,8 +2,8 @@ T-0/var/run/monitor-httpd.pid
 T-0/var/run/monitor/monitor-bootstrap.pid
 T-1/var/run/kedifa.pid
 T-1/var/run/monitor/monitor-bootstrap.pid
-T-2/var/run/caddy_graceful_signature
-T-2/var/run/caddy_validate_signature
-T-2/var/run/caddy_validate_signature.status
+T-2/var/run/caddy_configuration_last_state
+T-2/var/run/graceful_configuration_state_signature
 T-2/var/run/httpd.pid
 T-2/var/run/monitor/monitor-bootstrap.pid
+T-2/var/run/validate_configuration_state_signature
\ No newline at end of file

software/caddy-frontend/test/test_data/test.TestQuicEnabled.test_file_list_run-CADDY.txt

@@ -2,9 +2,9 @@ T-0/var/run/monitor-httpd.pid
 T-0/var/run/monitor/monitor-bootstrap.pid
 T-1/var/run/kedifa.pid
 T-1/var/run/monitor/monitor-bootstrap.pid
-T-2/var/run/caddy_graceful_signature
-T-2/var/run/caddy_validate_signature
-T-2/var/run/caddy_validate_signature.status
+T-2/var/run/caddy_configuration_last_state
+T-2/var/run/graceful_configuration_state_signature
 T-2/var/run/httpd.pid
 T-2/var/run/monitor-httpd.pid
 T-2/var/run/monitor/monitor-bootstrap.pid
+T-2/var/run/validate_configuration_state_signature
\ No newline at end of file

software/caddy-frontend/test/test_data/test.TestRe6stVerificationUrlDefaultSlave.test_file_list_run-CADDY.txt

@@ -2,9 +2,9 @@ T-0/var/run/monitor-httpd.pid
 T-0/var/run/monitor/monitor-bootstrap.pid
 T-1/var/run/kedifa.pid
 T-1/var/run/monitor/monitor-bootstrap.pid
-T-2/var/run/caddy_graceful_signature
-T-2/var/run/caddy_validate_signature
-T-2/var/run/caddy_validate_signature.status
+T-2/var/run/caddy_configuration_last_state
+T-2/var/run/graceful_configuration_state_signature
 T-2/var/run/httpd.pid
 T-2/var/run/monitor-httpd.pid
 T-2/var/run/monitor/monitor-bootstrap.pid
+T-2/var/run/validate_configuration_state_signature
\ No newline at end of file

software/caddy-frontend/test/test_data/test.TestRe6stVerificationUrlSlave.test_file_list_run-CADDY.txt

@@ -2,9 +2,9 @@ T-0/var/run/monitor-httpd.pid
 T-0/var/run/monitor/monitor-bootstrap.pid
 T-1/var/run/kedifa.pid
 T-1/var/run/monitor/monitor-bootstrap.pid
-T-2/var/run/caddy_graceful_signature
-T-2/var/run/caddy_validate_signature
-T-2/var/run/caddy_validate_signature.status
+T-2/var/run/caddy_configuration_last_state
+T-2/var/run/graceful_configuration_state_signature
 T-2/var/run/httpd.pid
 T-2/var/run/monitor-httpd.pid
 T-2/var/run/monitor/monitor-bootstrap.pid
+T-2/var/run/validate_configuration_state_signature
\ No newline at end of file

software/caddy-frontend/test/test_data/test.TestReplicateSlave.test_file_list_run-CADDY.txt

@@ -2,9 +2,9 @@ T-0/var/run/monitor-httpd.pid
 T-0/var/run/monitor/monitor-bootstrap.pid
 T-1/var/run/kedifa.pid
 T-1/var/run/monitor/monitor-bootstrap.pid
-T-2/var/run/caddy_graceful_signature
-T-2/var/run/caddy_validate_signature
-T-2/var/run/caddy_validate_signature.status
+T-2/var/run/caddy_configuration_last_state
+T-2/var/run/graceful_configuration_state_signature
 T-2/var/run/httpd.pid
 T-2/var/run/monitor-httpd.pid
 T-2/var/run/monitor/monitor-bootstrap.pid
+T-2/var/run/validate_configuration_state_signature
\ No newline at end of file

software/caddy-frontend/test/test_data/test.TestSlave.test_file_list_run-CADDY.txt

@@ -2,9 +2,9 @@ T-0/var/run/monitor-httpd.pid
 T-0/var/run/monitor/monitor-bootstrap.pid
 T-1/var/run/kedifa.pid
 T-1/var/run/monitor/monitor-bootstrap.pid
-T-2/var/run/caddy_graceful_signature
-T-2/var/run/caddy_validate_signature
-T-2/var/run/caddy_validate_signature.status
+T-2/var/run/caddy_configuration_last_state
+T-2/var/run/graceful_configuration_state_signature
 T-2/var/run/httpd.pid
 T-2/var/run/monitor-httpd.pid
 T-2/var/run/monitor/monitor-bootstrap.pid
+T-2/var/run/validate_configuration_state_signature
\ No newline at end of file

software/caddy-frontend/test/test_data/test.TestSlaveBadParameters.test_file_list_run-CADDY.txt

@@ -2,9 +2,9 @@ T-0/var/run/monitor-httpd.pid
 T-0/var/run/monitor/monitor-bootstrap.pid
 T-1/var/run/kedifa.pid
 T-1/var/run/monitor/monitor-bootstrap.pid
-T-2/var/run/caddy_graceful_signature
-T-2/var/run/caddy_validate_signature
-T-2/var/run/caddy_validate_signature.status
+T-2/var/run/caddy_configuration_last_state
+T-2/var/run/graceful_configuration_state_signature
 T-2/var/run/httpd.pid
 T-2/var/run/monitor-httpd.pid
 T-2/var/run/monitor/monitor-bootstrap.pid
+T-2/var/run/validate_configuration_state_signature
\ No newline at end of file

software/caddy-frontend/test/test_data/test.TestSlaveGlobalDisableHttp2.test_file_list_run-CADDY.txt

@@ -2,9 +2,9 @@ T-0/var/run/monitor-httpd.pid
 T-0/var/run/monitor/monitor-bootstrap.pid
 T-1/var/run/kedifa.pid
 T-1/var/run/monitor/monitor-bootstrap.pid
-T-2/var/run/caddy_graceful_signature
-T-2/var/run/caddy_validate_signature
-T-2/var/run/caddy_validate_signature.status
+T-2/var/run/caddy_configuration_last_state
+T-2/var/run/graceful_configuration_state_signature
 T-2/var/run/httpd.pid
 T-2/var/run/monitor-httpd.pid
 T-2/var/run/monitor/monitor-bootstrap.pid
+T-2/var/run/validate_configuration_state_signature
\ No newline at end of file

software/caddy-frontend/test/test_data/test.TestSlaveSlapOSMasterCertificateCompatibility.test_file_list_run-CADDY.txt

@@ -2,9 +2,9 @@ T-0/var/run/monitor-httpd.pid
 T-0/var/run/monitor/monitor-bootstrap.pid
 T-1/var/run/kedifa.pid
 T-1/var/run/monitor/monitor-bootstrap.pid
-T-2/var/run/caddy_graceful_signature
-T-2/var/run/caddy_validate_signature
-T-2/var/run/caddy_validate_signature.status
+T-2/var/run/caddy_configuration_last_state
+T-2/var/run/graceful_configuration_state_signature
 T-2/var/run/httpd.pid
 T-2/var/run/monitor-httpd.pid
 T-2/var/run/monitor/monitor-bootstrap.pid
+T-2/var/run/validate_configuration_state_signature
\ No newline at end of file

software/caddy-frontend/test/test_data/test.TestSlaveSlapOSMasterCertificateCompatibilityOverrideMaster.test_file_list_run-CADDY.txt

@@ -2,9 +2,9 @@ T-0/var/run/monitor-httpd.pid
 T-0/var/run/monitor/monitor-bootstrap.pid
 T-1/var/run/kedifa.pid
 T-1/var/run/monitor/monitor-bootstrap.pid
-T-2/var/run/caddy_graceful_signature
-T-2/var/run/caddy_validate_signature
-T-2/var/run/caddy_validate_signature.status
+T-2/var/run/caddy_configuration_last_state
+T-2/var/run/graceful_configuration_state_signature
 T-2/var/run/httpd.pid
 T-2/var/run/monitor-httpd.pid
 T-2/var/run/monitor/monitor-bootstrap.pid
+T-2/var/run/validate_configuration_state_signature
\ No newline at end of file

software/caddy-frontend/test/test_data/test.TestSlaveSlapOSMasterCertificateCompatibilityUpdate.test_file_list_run-CADDY.txt

@@ -2,9 +2,9 @@ T-0/var/run/monitor-httpd.pid
 T-0/var/run/monitor/monitor-bootstrap.pid
 T-1/var/run/kedifa.pid
 T-1/var/run/monitor/monitor-bootstrap.pid
-T-2/var/run/caddy_graceful_signature
-T-2/var/run/caddy_validate_signature
-T-2/var/run/caddy_validate_signature.status
+T-2/var/run/caddy_configuration_last_state
+T-2/var/run/graceful_configuration_state_signature
 T-2/var/run/httpd.pid
 T-2/var/run/monitor-httpd.pid
 T-2/var/run/monitor/monitor-bootstrap.pid
+T-2/var/run/validate_configuration_state_signature
\ No newline at end of file