Merge branch 'dm-fix-routes' into 'master'

Fix ambiguous routing issues by teaching router about reserved words

See merge request !11570

app/models/project.rb

@@ -205,7 +205,7 @@ class Project < ActiveRecord::Base
     presence: true,
     dynamic_path: true,
     length: { maximum: 255 },
-    format: { with: Gitlab::Regex.project_path_regex,
+    format: { with: Gitlab::Regex.project_path_format_regex,
               message: Gitlab::Regex.project_path_regex_message },
     uniqueness: { scope: :namespace_id }
 

app/validators/dynamic_path_validator.rb

@@ -6,199 +6,26 @@
 # Values are checked for formatting and exclusion from a list of reserved path
 # names.
 class DynamicPathValidator < ActiveModel::EachValidator
-  # All routes that appear on the top level must be listed here.
-  # This will make sure that groups cannot be created with these names
-  # as these routes would be masked by the paths already in place.
-  #
-  # Example:
-  #   /api/api-project
-  #
-  #  the path `api` shouldn't be allowed because it would be masked by `api/*`
-  #
-  TOP_LEVEL_ROUTES = %w[
-    -
-    .well-known
-    abuse_reports
-    admin
-    all
-    api
-    assets
-    autocomplete
-    ci
-    dashboard
-    explore
-    files
-    groups
-    health_check
-    help
-    hooks
-    import
-    invites
-    issues
-    jwt
-    koding
-    member
-    merge_requests
-    new
-    notes
-    notification_settings
-    oauth
-    profile
-    projects
-    public
-    repository
-    robots.txt
-    s
-    search
-    sent_notifications
-    services
-    snippets
-    teams
-    u
-    unicorn_test
-    unsubscribes
-    uploads
-    users
-  ].freeze
-
-  # This list should contain all words following `/*namespace_id/:project_id` in
-  # routes that contain a second wildcard.
-  #
-  # Example:
-  #   /*namespace_id/:project_id/badges/*ref/build
-  #
-  # If `badges` was allowed as a project/group name, we would not be able to access the
-  # `badges` route for those projects:
-  #
-  # Consider a namespace with path `foo/bar` and a project called `badges`.
-  # The route to the build badge would then be `/foo/bar/badges/badges/master/build.svg`
-  #
-  # When accessing this path the route would be matched to the `badges` path
-  # with the following params:
-  #   - namespace_id: `foo`
-  #   - project_id: `bar`
-  #   - ref: `badges/master`
-  #
-  # Failing to find the project, this would result in a 404.
-  #
-  # By rejecting `badges` the router can _count_ on the fact that `badges` will
-  # be preceded by the `namespace/project`.
-  WILDCARD_ROUTES = %w[
-    badges
-    blame
-    blob
-    builds
-    commits
-    create
-    create_dir
-    edit
-    environments/folders
-    files
-    find_file
-    gitlab-lfs/objects
-    info/lfs/objects
-    new
-    preview
-    raw
-    refs
-    tree
-    update
-    wikis
-  ].freeze
-
-  # These are all the paths that follow `/groups/*id/ or `/groups/*group_id`
-  # We need to reject these because we have a `/groups/*id` page that is the same
-  # as the `/*id`.
-  #
-  # If we would allow a subgroup to be created with the name `activity` then
-  # this group would not be accessible through `/groups/parent/activity` since
-  # this would map to the activity-page of it's parent.
-  GROUP_ROUTES = %w[
-    activity
-    analytics
-    audit_events
-    avatar
-    edit
-    group_members
-    hooks
-    issues
-    labels
-    ldap
-    ldap_group_links
-    merge_requests
-    milestones
-    notification_setting
-    pipeline_quota
-    projects
-    subgroups
-  ].freeze
-
-  CHILD_ROUTES = (WILDCARD_ROUTES | GROUP_ROUTES).freeze
-
-  def self.without_reserved_wildcard_paths_regex
-    @without_reserved_wildcard_paths_regex ||= regex_excluding_child_paths(WILDCARD_ROUTES)
-  end
-
-  def self.without_reserved_child_paths_regex
-    @without_reserved_child_paths_regex ||= regex_excluding_child_paths(CHILD_ROUTES)
-  end
-
-  # This is used to validate a full path.
-  # It doesn't match paths
-  #   - Starting with one of the top level words
-  #   - Containing one of the child level words in the middle of a path
-  def self.regex_excluding_child_paths(child_routes)
-    reserved_top_level_words = Regexp.union(TOP_LEVEL_ROUTES)
-    not_starting_in_reserved_word = %r{\A/?(?!(#{reserved_top_level_words})(/|\z))}
-
-    reserved_child_level_words = Regexp.union(child_routes)
-    not_containing_reserved_child = %r{(?!\S+/(#{reserved_child_level_words})(/|\z))}
-
-    %r{#{not_starting_in_reserved_word}
-       #{not_containing_reserved_child}
-       #{Gitlab::Regex.full_namespace_regex}}x
-  end
-
-  def self.valid?(path)
-    path =~ Gitlab::Regex.full_namespace_regex && !full_path_reserved?(path)
-  end
-
-  def self.full_path_reserved?(path)
-    path = path.to_s.downcase
-    _project_part, namespace_parts = path.reverse.split('/', 2).map(&:reverse)
-
-    wildcard_reserved?(path) || child_reserved?(namespace_parts)
-  end
-
-  def self.child_reserved?(path)
-    return false unless path
-
-    path !~ without_reserved_child_paths_regex
-  end
-
-  def self.wildcard_reserved?(path)
-    return false unless path
+  class << self
+    def valid_namespace_path?(path)
+      "#{path}/" =~ Gitlab::Regex.full_namespace_path_regex
+    end
 
-    path !~ without_reserved_wildcard_paths_regex
+    def valid_project_path?(path)
+      "#{path}/" =~ Gitlab::Regex.full_project_path_regex
+    end
   end
 
-  delegate :full_path_reserved?,
-           :child_reserved?,
-           to: :class
-
-  def path_reserved_for_record?(record, value)
+  def path_valid_for_record?(record, value)
     full_path = record.respond_to?(:full_path) ? record.full_path : value
 
-    # For group paths the entire path cannot contain a reserved child word
-    # The path doesn't contain the last `_project_part` so we need to validate
-    # if the entire path.
-    # Example:
-    #   A *group* with full path `parent/activity` is reserved.
-    #   A *project* with full path `parent/activity` is allowed.
-    if record.is_a? Group
-      child_reserved?(full_path)
+    return true unless full_path
+
+    case record
+    when Project
+      self.class.valid_project_path?(full_path)
     else
-      full_path_reserved?(full_path)
+      self.class.valid_namespace_path?(full_path)
     end
   end
 
@@ -208,7 +35,7 @@ class DynamicPathValidator < ActiveModel::EachValidator
       return
     end
 
-    if path_reserved_for_record?(record, value)
+    unless path_valid_for_record?(record, value)
       record.errors.add(attribute, "#{value} is a reserved name")
     end
   end

config/routes/admin.rb

@@ -68,7 +68,9 @@ namespace :admin do
 
   resources :projects, only: [:index]
 
-  scope(path: 'projects/*namespace_id', as: :namespace) do
+  scope(path: 'projects/*namespace_id',
+        as: :namespace,
+        constraints: { namespace_id: Gitlab::Regex.namespace_route_regex }) do
     resources(:projects,
               path: '/',
               constraints: { id: Gitlab::Regex.project_route_regex },

config/routes/git_http.rb

-scope(path: '*namespace_id/:project_id', constraints: { format: nil }) do
+scope(path: '*namespace_id/:project_id',
+      format: nil,
+      constraints: { namespace_id: Gitlab::Regex.namespace_route_regex }) do
   scope(constraints: { project_id: Gitlab::Regex.project_git_route_regex }, module: :projects) do
     # Git HTTP clients ('git clone' etc.)
     scope(controller: :git_http) do

config/routes/project.rb

@@ -5,7 +5,22 @@ resources :projects, only: [:index, :new, :create]
 draw :git_http
 
 constraints(ProjectUrlConstrainer.new) do
-  scope(path: '*namespace_id', as: :namespace) do
+  # If the route has a wildcard segment, the segment has a regex constraint,
+  # the segment is potentially followed by _another_ wildcard segment, and
+  # the `format` option is not set to false, we need to specify that
+  # regex constraint _outside_ of `constraints: {}`.
+  #
+  # Otherwise, Rails will overwrite the constraint with `/.+?/`,
+  # which breaks some of our wildcard routes like `/blob/*id`
+  # and `/tree/*id` that depend on the negative lookahead inside
+  # `Gitlab::Regex.namespace_route_regex`, which helps the router
+  # determine whether a certain path segment is part of `*namespace_id`,
+  # `:project_id`, or `*id`.
+  #
+  # See https://github.com/rails/rails/blob/v4.2.8/actionpack/lib/action_dispatch/routing/mapper.rb#L155
+  scope(path: '*namespace_id',
+        as: :namespace,
+        namespace_id: Gitlab::Regex.namespace_route_regex) do
     scope(path: ':project_id',
           constraints: { project_id: Gitlab::Regex.project_route_regex },
           module: :projects,

config/routes/user.rb

@@ -13,17 +13,17 @@ end
 
 constraints(UserUrlConstrainer.new) do
   # Get all keys of user
-  get ':username.keys' => 'profiles/keys#get_keys', constraints: { username: Gitlab::Regex.namespace_route_regex }
+  get ':username.keys' => 'profiles/keys#get_keys', constraints: { username: Gitlab::Regex.root_namespace_route_regex }
 
   scope(path: ':username',
         as: :user,
-        constraints: { username: Gitlab::Regex.namespace_route_regex },
+        constraints: { username: Gitlab::Regex.root_namespace_route_regex },
         controller: :users) do
     get '/', action: :show
   end
 end
 
-scope(constraints: { username: Gitlab::Regex.namespace_route_regex }) do
+scope(constraints: { username: Gitlab::Regex.root_namespace_route_regex }) do
   scope(path: 'users/:username',
         as: :user,
         controller: :users) do

doc/user/group/subgroups/index.md

@@ -71,9 +71,9 @@ structure.
 - You need to be an Owner of a group in order to be able to create
   a subgroup. For more information check the [permissions table][permissions].
 - For a list of words that are not allowed to be used as group names see the
-  [`dynamic_path_validator.rb` file][reserved] under the `TOP_LEVEL_ROUTES`, `WILDCARD_ROUTES` and `GROUP_ROUTES` lists:
+  [`regex.rb` file][reserved] under the `TOP_LEVEL_ROUTES`, `PROJECT_WILDCARD_ROUTES` and `GROUP_ROUTES` lists:
   - `TOP_LEVEL_ROUTES`: are names that are reserved as usernames or top level groups
-  - `WILDCARD_ROUTES`: are names that are reserved for child groups or projects.
+  - `PROJECT_WILDCARD_ROUTES`: are names that are reserved for child groups or projects.
   - `GROUP_ROUTES`: are names that are reserved for all groups or projects.
 
 To create a subgroup:
@@ -163,4 +163,4 @@ Here's a list of what you can't do with subgroups:
 
 [ce-2772]: https://gitlab.com/gitlab-org/gitlab-ce/issues/2772
 [permissions]: ../../permissions.md#group
-[reserved]:  https://gitlab.com/gitlab-org/gitlab-ce/blob/master/app/validators/dynamic_path_validator.rb
+[reserved]:  https://gitlab.com/gitlab-org/gitlab-ce/blob/master/lib/gitlab/regex.rb

lib/constraints/group_url_constrainer.rb

 class GroupUrlConstrainer
   def matches?(request)
-    id = request.params[:id]
+    id = request.params[:group_id] || request.params[:id]
 
-    return false unless DynamicPathValidator.valid?(id)
+    return false unless DynamicPathValidator.valid_namespace_path?(id)
 
     Group.find_by_full_path(id, follow_redirects: request.get?).present?
   end

lib/constraints/project_url_constrainer.rb

@@ -4,7 +4,7 @@ class ProjectUrlConstrainer
     project_path = request.params[:project_id] || request.params[:id]
     full_path = namespace_path + '/' + project_path
 
-    return false unless DynamicPathValidator.valid?(full_path)
+    return false unless DynamicPathValidator.valid_project_path?(full_path)
 
     Project.find_by_full_path(full_path, follow_redirects: request.get?).present?
   end

lib/gitlab/etag_caching/router.rb

@@ -10,7 +10,7 @@ module Gitlab
       #   - Ending in `issues/id`/realtime_changes` for the `issue_title` route
       USED_IN_ROUTES = %w[noteable issue notes issues realtime_changes
                           commit pipelines merge_requests new].freeze
-      RESERVED_WORDS = DynamicPathValidator::WILDCARD_ROUTES - USED_IN_ROUTES
+      RESERVED_WORDS = Gitlab::Regex::ILLEGAL_PROJECT_PATH_WORDS - USED_IN_ROUTES
       RESERVED_WORDS_REGEX = Regexp.union(*RESERVED_WORDS)
       ROUTES = [
         Gitlab::EtagCaching::Router::Route.new(

lib/gitlab/regex.rb

@@ -2,6 +2,136 @@ module Gitlab
   module Regex
     extend self
 
+    # All routes that appear on the top level must be listed here.
+    # This will make sure that groups cannot be created with these names
+    # as these routes would be masked by the paths already in place.
+    #
+    # Example:
+    #   /api/api-project
+    #
+    #  the path `api` shouldn't be allowed because it would be masked by `api/*`
+    #
+    TOP_LEVEL_ROUTES = %w[
+      -
+      .well-known
+      abuse_reports
+      admin
+      all
+      api
+      assets
+      autocomplete
+      ci
+      dashboard
+      explore
+      files
+      groups
+      health_check
+      help
+      hooks
+      import
+      invites
+      issues
+      jwt
+      koding
+      member
+      merge_requests
+      new
+      notes
+      notification_settings
+      oauth
+      profile
+      projects
+      public
+      repository
+      robots.txt
+      s
+      search
+      sent_notifications
+      services
+      snippets
+      teams
+      u
+      unicorn_test
+      unsubscribes
+      uploads
+      users
+    ].freeze
+
+    # This list should contain all words following `/*namespace_id/:project_id` in
+    # routes that contain a second wildcard.
+    #
+    # Example:
+    #   /*namespace_id/:project_id/badges/*ref/build
+    #
+    # If `badges` was allowed as a project/group name, we would not be able to access the
+    # `badges` route for those projects:
+    #
+    # Consider a namespace with path `foo/bar` and a project called `badges`.
+    # The route to the build badge would then be `/foo/bar/badges/badges/master/build.svg`
+    #
+    # When accessing this path the route would be matched to the `badges` path
+    # with the following params:
+    #   - namespace_id: `foo`
+    #   - project_id: `bar`
+    #   - ref: `badges/master`
+    #
+    # Failing to find the project, this would result in a 404.
+    #
+    # By rejecting `badges` the router can _count_ on the fact that `badges` will
+    # be preceded by the `namespace/project`.
+    PROJECT_WILDCARD_ROUTES = %w[
+      badges
+      blame
+      blob
+      builds
+      commits
+      create
+      create_dir
+      edit
+      environments/folders
+      files
+      find_file
+      gitlab-lfs/objects
+      info/lfs/objects
+      new
+      preview
+      raw
+      refs
+      tree
+      update
+      wikis
+    ].freeze
+
+    # These are all the paths that follow `/groups/*id/ or `/groups/*group_id`
+    # We need to reject these because we have a `/groups/*id` page that is the same
+    # as the `/*id`.
+    #
+    # If we would allow a subgroup to be created with the name `activity` then
+    # this group would not be accessible through `/groups/parent/activity` since
+    # this would map to the activity-page of its parent.
+    GROUP_ROUTES = %w[
+      activity
+      analytics
+      audit_events
+      avatar
+      edit
+      group_members
+      hooks
+      issues
+      labels
+      ldap
+      ldap_group_links
+      merge_requests
+      milestones
+      notification_setting
+      pipeline_quota
+      projects
+      subgroups
+    ].freeze
+
+    ILLEGAL_PROJECT_PATH_WORDS = PROJECT_WILDCARD_ROUTES
+    ILLEGAL_GROUP_PATH_WORDS = (PROJECT_WILDCARD_ROUTES | GROUP_ROUTES).freeze
+
     # The namespace regex is used in Javascript to validate usernames in the "Register" form. However, Javascript
     # does not support the negative lookbehind assertion (?<!) that disallows usernames ending in `.git` and `.atom`.
     # Since this is a non-trivial problem to solve in Javascript (heavily complicate the regex, modify view code to
@@ -18,6 +148,29 @@ module Gitlab
     # So `group/subgroup` will match this regex but not NAMESPACE_REGEX_STR
     FULL_NAMESPACE_REGEX_STR = "(?:#{NAMESPACE_REGEX_STR}/)*#{NAMESPACE_REGEX_STR}".freeze
 
+    def root_namespace_route_regex
+      @root_namespace_route_regex ||= begin
+        illegal_words = Regexp.new(Regexp.union(TOP_LEVEL_ROUTES).source, Regexp::IGNORECASE)
+
+        single_line_regexp %r{
+          (?!(#{illegal_words})/)
+          #{NAMESPACE_REGEX_STR}
+        }x
+      end
+    end
+
+    def root_namespace_path_regex
+      @root_namespace_path_regex ||= %r{\A#{root_namespace_route_regex}/\z}
+    end
+
+    def full_namespace_path_regex
+      @full_namespace_path_regex ||= %r{\A#{namespace_route_regex}/\z}
+    end
+
+    def full_project_path_regex
+      @full_project_path_regex ||= %r{\A#{namespace_route_regex}/#{project_route_regex}/\z}
+    end
+
     def namespace_regex
       @namespace_regex ||= /\A#{NAMESPACE_REGEX_STR}\z/.freeze
     end
@@ -27,7 +180,18 @@ module Gitlab
     end
 
     def namespace_route_regex
-      @namespace_route_regex ||= /#{NAMESPACE_REGEX_STR}/.freeze
+      @namespace_route_regex ||= begin
+        illegal_words = Regexp.new(Regexp.union(ILLEGAL_GROUP_PATH_WORDS).source, Regexp::IGNORECASE)
+
+        single_line_regexp %r{
+          #{root_namespace_route_regex}
+          (?:
+            /
+            (?!#{illegal_words}/)
+            #{NAMESPACE_REGEX_STR}
+          )*
+        }x
+      end
     end
 
     def namespace_regex_message
@@ -53,15 +217,26 @@ module Gitlab
     end
 
     def project_path_regex
-      @project_path_regex ||= /\A#{PROJECT_REGEX_STR}\z/.freeze
+      @project_path_regex ||= %r{\A#{project_route_regex}/\z}
     end
 
     def project_route_regex
-      @project_route_regex ||= /#{PROJECT_REGEX_STR}/.freeze
+      @project_route_regex ||= begin
+        illegal_words = Regexp.new(Regexp.union(ILLEGAL_PROJECT_PATH_WORDS).source, Regexp::IGNORECASE)
+
+        single_line_regexp %r{
+          (?!(#{illegal_words})/)
+          #{PROJECT_REGEX_STR}
+        }x
+      end
     end
 
     def project_git_route_regex
-      @project_route_git_regex ||= /#{PATH_REGEX_STR}\.git/.freeze
+      @project_git_route_regex ||= /#{project_route_regex}\.git/.freeze
+    end
+
+    def project_path_format_regex
+      @project_path_format_regex ||= /\A#{PROJECT_REGEX_STR}\z/.freeze
     end
 
     def project_path_regex_message
@@ -86,7 +261,7 @@ module Gitlab
       # Valid git ref regex, see:
       # https://www.kernel.org/pub/software/scm/git/docs/git-check-ref-format.html
 
-      @git_reference_regex ||= %r{
+      @git_reference_regex ||= single_line_regexp %r{
         (?!
            (?# doesn't begins with)
            \/|                    (?# rule #6)
@@ -102,7 +277,7 @@ module Gitlab
         (?# doesn't end with)
         (?<!\.lock)               (?# rule #1)
         (?<![\/.])                (?# rule #6-7)
-      }x.freeze
+      }x
     end
 
     def container_registry_reference_regex
@@ -140,5 +315,13 @@ module Gitlab
       "can contain only lowercase letters, digits, and '-'. " \
       "Must start with a letter, and cannot end with '-'"
     end
+
+    private
+
+    def single_line_regexp(regex)
+      # Turns a multiline extended regexp into a single line one,
+      # beacuse `rake routes` breaks on multiline regexes.
+      Regexp.new(regex.source.gsub(/\(\?#.+?\)/, '').gsub(/\s*/, ''), regex.options ^ Regexp::EXTENDED).freeze
+    end
   end
 end

spec/controllers/import/gitlab_controller_spec.rb

@@ -174,7 +174,7 @@ describe Import::GitlabController do
           end
         end
       end
-      
+
       context 'user has chosen an existing nested namespace for the project' do
         let(:parent_namespace) { create(:namespace, name: 'foo', owner: user) }
         let(:nested_namespace) { create(:namespace, name: 'bar', parent: parent_namespace, owner: user) }

spec/models/namespace_spec.rb

@@ -37,7 +37,7 @@ describe Namespace, models: true do
 
         it 'rejects nested paths' do
           parent = create(:group, :nested, path: 'environments')
-          namespace = build(:project, path: 'folders', namespace: parent)
+          namespace = build(:group, path: 'folders', parent: parent)
 
           expect(namespace).not_to be_valid
         end

spec/routing/project_routing_spec.rb

@@ -462,6 +462,8 @@ describe 'project routing' do
       expect(get('/gitlab/gitlabhq/blob/master/app/models/compare.rb')).to route_to('projects/blob#show', namespace_id: 'gitlab', project_id: 'gitlabhq', id: 'master/app/models/compare.rb')
       expect(get('/gitlab/gitlabhq/blob/master/app/models/diff.js')).to route_to('projects/blob#show', namespace_id: 'gitlab', project_id: 'gitlabhq', id: 'master/app/models/diff.js')
       expect(get('/gitlab/gitlabhq/blob/master/files.scss')).to route_to('projects/blob#show', namespace_id: 'gitlab', project_id: 'gitlabhq', id: 'master/files.scss')
+      expect(get('/gitlab/gitlabhq/blob/master/blob/index.js')).to route_to('projects/blob#show', namespace_id: 'gitlab', project_id: 'gitlabhq', id: 'master/blob/index.js')
+      expect(get('/gitlab/gitlabhq/blob/blob/master/blob/index.js')).to route_to('projects/blob#show', namespace_id: 'gitlab', project_id: 'gitlabhq', id: 'blob/master/blob/index.js')
     end
   end
 
@@ -470,6 +472,8 @@ describe 'project routing' do
     it 'to #show' do
       expect(get('/gitlab/gitlabhq/tree/master/app/models/project.rb')).to route_to('projects/tree#show', namespace_id: 'gitlab', project_id: 'gitlabhq', id: 'master/app/models/project.rb')
       expect(get('/gitlab/gitlabhq/tree/master/files.scss')).to route_to('projects/tree#show', namespace_id: 'gitlab', project_id: 'gitlabhq', id: 'master/files.scss')
+      expect(get('/gitlab/gitlabhq/tree/master/tree/files')).to route_to('projects/tree#show', namespace_id: 'gitlab', project_id: 'gitlabhq', id: 'master/tree/files')
+      expect(get('/gitlab/gitlabhq/tree/tree/master/tree/files')).to route_to('projects/tree#show', namespace_id: 'gitlab', project_id: 'gitlabhq', id: 'tree/master/tree/files')
     end
   end
 

spec/validators/dynamic_path_validator_spec.rb

@@ -3,246 +3,46 @@ require 'spec_helper'
 describe DynamicPathValidator do
   let(:validator) { described_class.new(attributes: [:path]) }
 
-  # Pass in a full path to remove the format segment:
-  # `/ci/lint(.:format)` -> `/ci/lint`
-  def without_format(path)
-    path.split('(', 2)[0]
-  end
-
-  # Pass in a full path and get the last segment before a wildcard
-  # That's not a parameter
-  # `/*namespace_id/:project_id/builds/artifacts/*ref_name_and_path`
-  #    -> 'builds/artifacts'
-  def path_before_wildcard(path)
-    path = path.gsub(STARTING_WITH_NAMESPACE, "")
-    path_segments = path.split('/').reject(&:empty?)
-    wildcard_index = path_segments.index { |segment| parameter?(segment) }
-
-    segments_before_wildcard = path_segments[0..wildcard_index - 1]
-
-    segments_before_wildcard.join('/')
-  end
-
-  def parameter?(segment)
-    segment =~ /[*:]/
-  end
-
-  # If the path is reserved. Then no conflicting paths can# be created for any
-  # route using this reserved word.
-  #
-  # Both `builds/artifacts` & `build` are covered by reserving the word
-  # `build`
-  def wildcards_include?(path)
-    described_class::WILDCARD_ROUTES.include?(path) ||
-      described_class::WILDCARD_ROUTES.include?(path.split('/').first)
-  end
-
-  def failure_message(missing_words, constant_name, migration_helper)
-    missing_words = Array(missing_words)
-    <<-MSG
-      Found new routes that could cause conflicts with existing namespaced routes
-      for groups or projects.
+  describe '#path_valid_for_record?' do
+    context 'for project' do
+      it 'calls valid_project_path?' do
+        project = build(:project, path: 'activity')
 
-      Add <#{missing_words.join(', ')}> to `DynamicPathValidator::#{constant_name}
-      to make sure no projects or namespaces can be created with those paths.
+        expect(described_class).to receive(:valid_project_path?).with(project.full_path).and_call_original
 
-      To rename any existing records with those paths you can use the
-      `Gitlab::Database::RenameReservedpathsMigration::<VERSION>.#{migration_helper}`
-      migration helper.
-
-      Make sure to make a note of the renamed records in the release blog post.
-
-    MSG
-  end
-
-  let(:all_routes) do
-    Rails.application.routes.routes.routes.
-      map { |r| r.path.spec.to_s }
-  end
-
-  let(:routes_without_format) { all_routes.map { |path| without_format(path) } }
-
-  # Routes not starting with `/:` or `/*`
-  # all routes not starting with a param
-  let(:routes_not_starting_in_wildcard) { routes_without_format.select { |p| p !~ %r{^/[:*]} } }
-
-  let(:top_level_words) do
-    routes_not_starting_in_wildcard.map do |route|
-      route.split('/')[1]
-    end.compact.uniq
-  end
-
-  # All routes that start with a namespaced path, that have 1 or more
-  # path-segments before having another wildcard parameter.
-  # - Starting with paths:
-  #   - `/*namespace_id/:project_id/`
-  #   - `/*namespace_id/:id/`
-  # - Followed by one or more path-parts not starting with `:` or `*`
-  # - Followed by a path-part that includes a wildcard parameter `*`
-  # At the time of writing these routes match: http://rubular.com/r/Rv2pDE5Dvw
-  STARTING_WITH_NAMESPACE = %r{^/\*namespace_id/:(project_)?id}
-  NON_PARAM_PARTS = %r{[^:*][a-z\-_/]*}
-  ANY_OTHER_PATH_PART = %r{[a-z\-_/:]*}
-  WILDCARD_SEGMENT = %r{\*}
-  let(:namespaced_wildcard_routes) do
-    routes_without_format.select do |p|
-      p =~ %r{#{STARTING_WITH_NAMESPACE}/#{NON_PARAM_PARTS}/#{ANY_OTHER_PATH_PART}#{WILDCARD_SEGMENT}}
-    end
-  end
-
-  # This will return all paths that are used in a namespaced route
-  # before another wildcard path:
-  #
-  # /*namespace_id/:project_id/builds/artifacts/*ref_name_and_path
-  # /*namespace_id/:project_id/info/lfs/objects/*oid
-  # /*namespace_id/:project_id/commits/*id
-  # /*namespace_id/:project_id/builds/:build_id/artifacts/file/*path
-  # -> ['builds/artifacts', 'info/lfs/objects', 'commits', 'artifacts/file']
-  let(:all_wildcard_paths) do
-    namespaced_wildcard_routes.map do |route|
-      path_before_wildcard(route)
-    end.uniq
-  end
-
-  STARTING_WITH_GROUP = %r{^/groups/\*(group_)?id/}
-  let(:group_routes) do
-    routes_without_format.select do |path|
-      path =~ STARTING_WITH_GROUP
-    end
-  end
-
-  let(:paths_after_group_id) do
-    group_routes.map do |route|
-      route.gsub(STARTING_WITH_GROUP, '').split('/').first
-    end.uniq
-  end
-
-  describe 'TOP_LEVEL_ROUTES' do
-    it 'includes all the top level namespaces' do
-      failure_block = lambda do
-        missing_words = top_level_words - described_class::TOP_LEVEL_ROUTES
-        failure_message(missing_words, 'TOP_LEVEL_ROUTES', 'rename_root_paths')
+        expect(validator.path_valid_for_record?(project, 'activity')).to be_truthy
       end
-
-      expect(described_class::TOP_LEVEL_ROUTES)
-        .to include(*top_level_words), failure_block
     end
-  end
 
-  describe 'GROUP_ROUTES' do
-    it "don't contain a second wildcard" do
-      failure_block = lambda do
-        missing_words = paths_after_group_id - described_class::GROUP_ROUTES
-        failure_message(missing_words, 'GROUP_ROUTES', 'rename_child_paths')
-      end
+    context 'for group' do
+      it 'calls valid_namespace_path?' do
+        group = build(:group, :nested, path: 'activity')
 
-      expect(described_class::GROUP_ROUTES)
-        .to include(*paths_after_group_id), failure_block
-    end
-  end
+        expect(described_class).to receive(:valid_namespace_path?).with(group.full_path).and_call_original
 
-  describe 'WILDCARD_ROUTES' do
-    it 'includes all paths that can be used after a namespace/project path' do
-      aggregate_failures do
-        all_wildcard_paths.each do |path|
-          expect(wildcards_include?(path))
-            .to be(true), failure_message(path, 'WILDCARD_ROUTES', 'rename_wildcard_paths')
-        end
+        expect(validator.path_valid_for_record?(group, 'activity')).to be_falsey
       end
     end
-  end
 
-  describe '.without_reserved_wildcard_paths_regex' do
-    subject { described_class.without_reserved_wildcard_paths_regex }
+    context 'for user' do
+      it 'calls valid_namespace_path?' do
+        user = build(:user, username: 'activity')
 
-    it 'rejects paths starting with a reserved top level' do
-      expect(subject).not_to match('dashboard/hello/world')
-      expect(subject).not_to match('dashboard')
-    end
+        expect(described_class).to receive(:valid_namespace_path?).with(user.full_path).and_call_original
 
-    it 'matches valid paths with a toplevel word in a different place' do
-      expect(subject).to match('parent/dashboard/project-path')
-    end
-
-    it 'rejects paths containing a wildcard reserved word' do
-      expect(subject).not_to match('hello/edit')
-      expect(subject).not_to match('hello/edit/in-the-middle')
-      expect(subject).not_to match('foo/bar1/refs/master/logs_tree')
-    end
-
-    it 'matches valid paths' do
-      expect(subject).to match('parent/child/project-path')
-    end
-  end
-
-  describe '.regex_excluding_child_paths' do
-    let(:subject) { described_class.without_reserved_child_paths_regex }
-
-    it 'rejects paths containing a child reserved word' do
-      expect(subject).not_to match('hello/group_members')
-      expect(subject).not_to match('hello/activity/in-the-middle')
-      expect(subject).not_to match('foo/bar1/refs/master/logs_tree')
-    end
-
-    it 'allows a child path on the top level' do
-      expect(subject).to match('activity/foo')
-      expect(subject).to match('avatar')
-    end
-  end
-
-  describe ".valid?" do
-    it 'is not case sensitive' do
-      expect(described_class.valid?("Users")).to be_falsey
-    end
-
-    it "isn't valid when the top level is reserved" do
-      test_path = 'u/should-be-a/reserved-word'
-
-      expect(described_class.valid?(test_path)).to be_falsey
-    end
-
-    it "isn't valid if any of the path segments is reserved" do
-      test_path = 'the-wildcard/wikis/is-not-allowed'
-
-      expect(described_class.valid?(test_path)).to be_falsey
-    end
-
-    it "is valid if the path doesn't contain reserved words" do
-      test_path = 'there-are/no-wildcards/in-this-path'
-
-      expect(described_class.valid?(test_path)).to be_truthy
-    end
-
-    it 'allows allows a child path on the last spot' do
-      test_path = 'there/can-be-a/project-called/labels'
-
-      expect(described_class.valid?(test_path)).to be_truthy
-    end
-
-    it 'rejects a child path somewhere else' do
-      test_path = 'there/can-be-no/labels/group'
-
-      expect(described_class.valid?(test_path)).to be_falsey
+        expect(validator.path_valid_for_record?(user, 'activity')).to be_truthy
+      end
     end
 
-    it 'rejects paths that are in an incorrect format' do
-      test_path = 'incorrect/format.git'
-
-      expect(described_class.valid?(test_path)).to be_falsey
-    end
-  end
+    context 'for user namespace' do
+      it 'calls valid_namespace_path?' do
+        user = create(:user, username: 'activity')
+        namespace = user.namespace
 
-  describe '#path_reserved_for_record?' do
-    it 'reserves a sub-group named activity' do
-      group = build(:group, :nested, path: 'activity')
+        expect(described_class).to receive(:valid_namespace_path?).with(namespace.full_path).and_call_original
 
-      expect(validator.path_reserved_for_record?(group, 'activity')).to be_truthy
-    end
-
-    it "doesn't reserve a project called activity" do
-      project = build(:project, path: 'activity')
-
-      expect(validator.path_reserved_for_record?(project, 'activity')).to be_falsey
+        expect(validator.path_valid_for_record?(namespace, 'activity')).to be_truthy
+      end
     end
   end