• Eric Biggers's avatar
    crypto: x86/sha-mb - decrease priority of multibuffer algorithms · 8aeef492
    Eric Biggers authored
    With all the crypto modules enabled on x86, and with a CPU that supports
    AVX-2 but not SHA-NI instructions (e.g. Haswell, Broadwell, Skylake),
    the "multibuffer" implementations of SHA-1, SHA-256, and SHA-512 are the
    highest priority.  However, these implementations only perform well when
    many hash requests are being submitted concurrently, filling all 8 AVX-2
    lanes.  Otherwise, they are incredibly slow, as they waste time waiting
    for more requests to arrive before proceeding to execute each request.
    
    For example, here are the speeds I see hashing 4096-byte buffers with a
    single thread on a Haswell-based processor:
    
                generic            avx2          mb (multibuffer)
                -------            --------      ----------------
    sha1        602 MB/s           997 MB/s      0.61 MB/s
    sha256      228 MB/s           412 MB/s      0.61 MB/s
    sha512      312 MB/s           559 MB/s      0.61 MB/s
    
    So, the multibuffer implementation is 500 to 1000 times slower than the
    other implementations.  Note that with smaller buffers or more update()s
    per digest, the difference would be even greater.
    
    I believe the vast majority of people are in the boat where the
    multibuffer code is much slower, and only a small minority are doing the
    highly parallel, hashing-intensive, latency-flexible workloads (maybe
    IPsec on servers?) where the multibuffer code may be beneficial.  Yet,
    people often aren't familiar with all the crypto config options and so
    the multibuffer code may inadvertently be built into the kernel.
    
    Also the multibuffer code apparently hasn't been very well tested,
    seeing as it was sometimes computing the wrong SHA-256 digest.
    
    So, let's make the multibuffer algorithms low priority.  Users who want
    to use them can either request them explicitly by driver name, or use
    NETLINK_CRYPTO (crypto_user) to increase their priority at runtime.
    Signed-off-by: default avatarEric Biggers <ebiggers@google.com>
    Signed-off-by: default avatarHerbert Xu <herbert@gondor.apana.org.au>
    8aeef492
sha1_mb.c 27.3 KB